Decision-anxiety: a perfectionist's guide to making imperfect decisions

Debunking the myth of the perfect choice and why we overthink our decisions. Learn practical strategies to move from analysis paralysis to confident action.

I don't know about you, but I regularly meet brilliant, capable people in my daily life and therapy practice who can analyze and solve complex workplace problems but spend weeks agonizing over personal decisions.

The Modern Curse of Choice

Here's the thing about living in today's world of infinite possibilities: we have more choices than any generation in human history, yet we're more paralyzed by decision-making than ever before. Our great-great-grandparents didn't spend hours researching the "best" coffee maker on Amazon—they had limited options at the general store, and life went on just fine.

But now? We've got 27 different types of oat milk to choose from and somehow this feels overwhelming rather than liberating. What's going on here?

The culprit is what I call "The Hamlet Complex"—that torturous belief that if we just think hard enough, analyze long enough, and gather enough data, we'll arrive at the Perfect Decision™. Spoiler alert: it's a myth, and perfect doesn't exist.

The Illusion of the "Right" Choice

In my practice, I often work with anxious clients who've convinced themselves that there's an objectively correct answer to every life decision. Should I take that job? Move to that city? End this relationship? They come to therapy hoping I'll help them find the "right" answer, as if life were a multiple-choice test with an answer key hidden somewhere.

But here's what I've learned: the belief that you can think your way to certainty is not just wrong—it's actively harmful to your mental health.

Think about it: even theoretical physicists have given up on absolute predictability (thanks, Heisenberg). Yet we expect ourselves to perfectly forecast whether that career change will make us happy in five years? The bar we're setting for ourselves is literally impossible to clear.

Why Your Brain Isn't Built for This

Our rational mind loves the fantasy that more information equals better decisions. It feels productive to make pro-and-con lists, to research endlessly, to seek just one more opinion. But what's really happening is we're using our thinking brain to avoid the discomfort of uncertainty.

The uncomfortable truth? Good decision-making isn't about eliminating uncertainty—it's about getting comfortable with it.

I had a client who spent months researching preschools for her three-year-old. She created spreadsheets, visited nine schools, and lost sleep over teacher-to-student ratios. When she finally chose one, her daughter hated it and wanted to switch after two weeks. Life, as it turns out, doesn't always cooperate with our perfect plans.

The Four Pillars of Healthy Decision-Making

After years of working with decision-anxious clients, I've identified four key shifts that transform how people approach choices:

1. Embrace The Trade-Off

Every decision involves trade-offs, and that's not a bug in the system—it's a feature. When you choose the beach vacation, you're not choosing the mountain retreat. When you commit to the relationship, you're closing off other romantic possibilities. When you order the pasta, you're not getting the salmon.

This isn't tragic; it's just reality. The sooner you make peace with the fact that all choices involve sacrifice and let go of that choice you didn’t make, the sooner you'll stop torturing yourself trying to find the choice that doesn't.

I tell my clients: "You're not looking for the perfect decision—you're looking for the decision you can live with most peacefully."

2. Trust Your Instinct

Here's where I might lose some of my more analytically-minded readers, but stay with me: your instincts often have access to information your conscious mind doesn't. That "gut feeling" isn't mystical nonsense—it's your brain processing thousands of subtle cues below the threshold of awareness.

I teach clients a simple technique: Before making big decisions, spend a few minutes visualizing each option while lying in bed about to fall asleep. Don't analyze the options; just picture yourself living out each choice as if you were watching a silent movie. Notice how your body responds. Does one path feel expansive? Does another feel constrictive? Your body often recognizes patterns your mind hasn't consciously identified yet.

3. Learn to Dance with Uncertainty

Here's what nobody tells you about uncertainty: it's not the enemy of good decision-making—it's the dance partner you need to learn to move with. I've watched countless clients exhaust themselves trying to eliminate uncertainty from their choices, when the real skill is learning to move forward despite it.

Think of uncertainty like weather. You can check the forecast, pack an umbrella, and dress in layers, but you can't control whether it rains. The people who thrive aren't those who never encounter storms—they're the ones who've learned to navigate whatever weather shows up.

In therapy, I often ask clients: "What if uncertainty isn't something to solve, but something to surf?"

4. Get Clear on Your Values

Instead of endlessly weighing pros and cons, ask yourself: "What matters most to me in this situation?" Your values become your North Star when the information gets murky.

Maybe family closeness trumps career advancement for you right now. Maybe adventure matters more than security. Maybe helping others is worth the financial sacrifice. When you're clear on your core values, decisions become less about finding the "right" answer and more about staying true to who you are.

The Freedom of "Good Enough"

One of the most liberating realizations in therapy is understanding that most decisions are reversible or adjustable. The job you take isn't necessarily the job you'll keep forever. The city you move to isn't where you have to die. The relationship you commit to can evolve or, yes, sometimes end.

This isn't about being cavalier with important choices—it's about recognizing that life is a series of course corrections, not a single perfect trajectory you need to identify in advance.

Your Action Plan: The MAGIC Method

Next time you find yourself stuck in analysis paralysis, try this five-step approach:

1. Set a decision deadline (and stick to it)

2. Gather enough information to feel informed, not exhaustive

3. Check in with your gut feeling

4. Identify your top value in this situation

5. Make the choice and commit to making it work

Remember: there's no decision so perfect that it will eliminate all future uncertainty from your life. But there is a way of making decisions that builds confidence, clarifies your values, and keeps you moving forward rather than spinning in circles.

The Bottom Line

The goal isn't to become someone who never struggles with choices—it's to become someone who doesn't let the struggle paralyze them.

Your future self isn't waiting for you to make the perfect decision; they're waiting for you to make a decision and then make it work. Stop overthinking. Start living.

---

What decision have you been avoiding? Pick one small choice you've been putting off and apply the above method this week. Your future self will thank you.

---